They agreed to come to the assistance of their Greek brethren when it was over, but it would be a week or more before their feared hoplites (citizen soldiers) would be in battle position where the Athenians needed them. Pheidippides ( Greek: "Son of Phedippos") or Philippides () is the central figure in the story that inspired a modern sporting event, the marathon race. The Persian Empire, seeking to punish Athens for . circa 490 BC. How about that? The two forces had been eyeballing each other for several days over the swampy plain. After he reached Athens, the city deployed 10,000 adult male Athenian citizens to Marathon to fend off 60,000 Persians. 4, viii. Right after he delivered his message, Pheidippides died of exhaustion. Odds & lines subject to change. Heres an overview of who Pheidippides was and the real details of the historic events surrounding his noble actions and also of his death. But the moon wasnt full, and religious law forbade the Spartans to battle until it was, which wouldnt be for another six days time. His one-man race was Michel Brals inspiration for the modern, less-deadly, marathon. What they did was considered beyond competition, more akin to something . Pheidippides (5th century bc ), Athenian messenger, who was sent to Sparta to ask for help after the Persian landing at Marathon in 490 and is said to have covered the 250 km (150 miles) in two days on foot. Apparently his plea was convincing, for it worked. At the modern-day Spartathlon, Id supposedly retrace those steps. This is how Pheidippides likely fueled during his run, and how I ran the race, too. Athens won the battle, but now it was up to Pheidippides to make the run from Marathon to Athens, a distance of 40 kilometers or about 25 miles. Then it happened again, and I realized I was sleep running. *Dont believe the propaganda, by the way: the action at the Hot Gates was a terrible tactical and strategic defeat for Leonidas, who was definitely not fighting a mere delaying action (and also he ended up dead, which sucked for him). Run, Pheidippides, one race more! I felt a closeness to Pheidippides and I resolved to learn what really took place out there on the hillsides of ancient Greece. Everyone loved the idea, especially the Greeks, hosts to the first modern Olympic Games in Athens in 1896.The Greeks loved the marathon even more after one of their own--the only Greek winner in those first Games--captured the approximately 25 mile run from Marathon to Athens. In fact, it is more likely that he ran a much greater distance than 26 miles. And 5,000 to 6,000 Athenian soldiers did complete a post-battle jog from Marathon to Athens, 22 to 25 miles, in about six to seven hours. So, when Persia was dust, all cried, "To Acropolis!Run, Pheidippides, one race more! He ran about 240km (150mi) in two days, and then ran back. After he gave his message, he promptly dropped dead from the exertion. As he sprinted the 150 miles, 11,000 Greek infantry men waited near the approaching 30,000 Persian invaders that had landed on the coast of Marathon. Not much is known about Pheidippides, the Athenian soldier despatched by his generals to Sparta to enlist the help of the Spartans in the Athenians' quarrel with the Persians. Athens. 28. The distance between Marathon and Athens is about 26 miles, and todays marathon races have beencreated to commemorate that. Pheidippides returns by the same route, carrying the news that the Athenians will have to face the forces of King Darius I alone. There's even a movie about the event. Ancient Greek athletes were known to eat figs and other fruits, olives, dried meats, and a particular concoction composed of ground sesame seeds and honey mixed into a paste (now called pasteli). As the well-worn legend goes, after the badly outnumbered Greeks somehow managed to drive back the Persians who had invaded the coastal plain of Marathon, an Athenian messenger named Pheidippides was dispatched from the battlefield to Athens to deliver the news of Greek victory. The race became the highlight of the Games and was won by Spyridon Louis, a. ), .css-17zuyas{display:block;font-family:Sailec,Sailec-fallback,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:bold;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-17zuyas:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-17zuyas{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-17zuyas{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;}}@media(min-width: 48rem){.css-17zuyas{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-17zuyas{font-size:1.2rem;line-height:1.4;}}.css-17zuyas h2 span:hover{color:#CDCDCD;}7 Strategies for Building Endurance, Try This Partner Workout With Your Gym Buddy, A Bodyweight Workout to Harness Your Endurance, Why B+ Workouts Are Better Than A+ Workouts, Why You Should Be Training to Run Downhill, 4 Treadmill Workouts for All Your Run Goals, How Fitness Classes Can Boost Your Race Times, 7 Eccentric Quad Exercises to Prep for Downhills. Pheidippides. Oct. 26: The Truth about Pheidippides and the Early Years of Marathon History, From Runner's World for Orangetheory Fitness, Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. Our editors will review what youve submitted and determine whether to revise the article. The vision of a young man heralding victory, moments . The marathon race was instituted in commemoration of the fabled run of the Greek soldier named Pheidippides. Robert Browning gave a version of the traditional story in his 1879 poem "Pheidippides". The Athenians thrusting spears gave them an advantage in hand-to-hand fighting. After he gave his message to the Spartans requesting their help, he turned around and ran the distance from Sparta to Athens to let them know that the Spartans wouldnt be able to fight right away. Training and life became inseparable, one and the same, intimately intertwined. Much is written about the training and preparation of Olympic athletes, and quite detailed accounts of the early Greek Games exist. To the ancient Greeks, nothing could be nobler than dying after performing a heroic deed for ones country. He is an older Athenian citizen and a farmer. Strepsiades wakes before dawn with worries about his debt. And then he promptly collapsed from exhaustion and died. Pheidippides (Greek: , sometimes given as Phidippides, by Herodotus and Plutarch, or as Philippides), hero of Ancient Greece, is the central figure in a story that was the inspiration for a modern sporting event, the marathon. The Athenians believed Pheidippides's story, and when their affairs were once more in a prosperous state, they built a shrine to Pan under the Acropolis, and from the time his message was received they held an annual ceremony, with a torch-race and sacrifices, to court his protection.On the occasion of which I speak when Pheidippides, that is, was sent on his mission by the Athenian commanders and said that he saw Pan he reached Sparta the day after he left Athens and delivered his message to the Spartan government. Pheidippides is said to have run from Marathon to Athens to deliver news of the victory of the battle of Marathon. The first time we hear this story with a messenger called Pheidippides (or Philippides) is in Lucian, and by that time we're in the second century AD, around 600 years after the Battle of Marathon. Bad casting? For example, running played a big role in the battle, though a key distance covered was about a mile, not 26.2 miles. Strepsiades is the anti-hero of Aristophanes's play. Using briliant tactics, the Athenians achieve a decisive victory. A costume which, due to unintended circumstances, I'm now thinking about wearing from Marathon to Athens next Sunday, Oct. 31, in the Athens Marathon that celebrates the 2500th birthday of the famous Battle of Marathon.Running in LiteratureRunning TimeMarathon & Beyond,hemerodromoi, didThe Fifteen Decisive Battles of the World The Marathon Footrace; and many other sourcesIf Robert Browning killed off Pheidippides with his poem of 1878, he also launched the marathon as a exalted athletic event. His mission was to rally support from the Spartans to help repel the Persian army, which was preparing to invade. On his last assisted fall, he crumbled across the finish in 2:54:47. Sappho was a famous Greek . Of the Athenians Creasy wrote: "On the result of their deliberations depended, not merely the fate of two armies, but the whole future progress of civilisation. After running about 25 miles to the Acropolis, he burst into the chambers and gallantly hailed his countrymen with Nike! Pheidippides story is immortalized in paintings, poetry, and every time someone runs a marathon. To think that an ancient hemerodromos was running here 2,500 years ago fascinated me, and knowing that this was the land of my ancestors made the experience even more visceral. At the start, I was surrounded by 350 warriors huddled in the predawn mist at the foot of the Acropolis of Athens. It was a stark reminder that while some things hadnt changed since ancient times, other things had. Certainly not that the figure to the right is a living Pheidippides. Still, I pressed on. The story of this messenger from the Battle of Marathon was later . Comparatively little is recorded of the mysterious hemerodromoi other than that they covered incredible distances on foot, over rocky and mountainous terrain, forgoing sleep if need be in carrying out their duties as messengers. In Boston, the marathon thrived, and the Boston Marathon gained worldwide fame as the longest, continuously organized marathon in the world. Ran like fire once more: and the space twixt the Fennel-field Don't scoff. Legend tells of Pheidippides, who fought at the battle of Marathon. [original research?]. "Krenz doubts that the Athenians marched back to Athens the same day, as recounted by Billows. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. The Athenians were outnumbered two or three to one, so the sensible thing to do was to hunker down and wait for reinforcements, which were supposed to be on their way from Sparta. [original research? . Pheidippides ( Greek: , sometimes given as Phidippides, by Herodotus and Plutarch, [ 1] or as Philippides ), hero of Ancient Greece, is the central figure in a story which was the inspiration for a modern sporting event, the marathon. It felt like the right way to tell his storythe actual story of the marathon. 19. Men of Sparta, he reportedly said, the Athenians beseech you to hasten to their aide, and not allow that state, which is the most ancient in all of Greece, to be enslaved by the barbarians.. ; Athenian courier who ran to Sparta to seek aid against the Persians before the battle of Marathon. Phidippides cardiomyopathy refers to the cardiomyopathic changes that occurs after long periods of endurance training.It was named after Phidippides, the famous Greek runner who died after running from Marathon to Athens in 490 BC.. And the nose was assaulted by a pungent array of smells: the sweat of struggling men, the sweetish, coppery smell of blood, and above all, no doubt, the acrid scent of piss and dank stink of shit as fear, trauma, and death caused men's bladders and bowels to be loosened. Greece is famous for Athens, its capital city. He was a messenger who reported the victory by running from the Battle of Marathon to Athens. . They looked for assistance in the most violent of all Greek polis, the Spartans to the south. Instead, its the entire Athenian army which makes the trek. Pheidippides (5th century bc), Athenian messenger, who was sent to Sparta to ask for help after the Persian landing at Marathon in 490 and is said to have covered the 250 km (150 miles) in two days on foot. Terms at draftkings.com/sportsbook. Sam Stoller was a Jewish-American sprinter, who is most famous for being excluded from the American 4X100 relay team at the 1936 Olympics in Berlin, apparently to appease Hitler. When he arrived, the Spartans were five days into a nine-day religious festival, the Carneia, during which they were forbidden to fight. We earn a commission for products purchased through some links in this article. Kenyan Eliud Kipchoge holds the best men's marathon time of all time (2:01:09), obtained in Berlin on September 25, 2022; and Kenyan Brigid Kosgei holds the best women's time (2:14:04), obtained in Chicago on October 13 . Based on this account, British RAF Wing Commander John Foden and four other RAF officers travelled to Greece in 1982 on an official expedition to . Interestingly, though we generally credit Pheidippides as the first marathon runner and run the modern marathon distance of 26.2 miles based on the myth of Pheidippides, there's another modern race that's also modeled after the legendary runs of Pheidippides. While Herodotus doesnt mention a solo runner going ahead of the main phalanx from Marathon to Athens, it is possible that a messenger was sent to inform the terrified citizens that the army was returning and to instruct them not to surrender. (4:14) . This was important because Pan, in addition to his other powers, had the capacity to instill an irrational, blind fear that paralyzed the mind and suspended all sense of judgment panic. Exhausted as he was, Pheidippidess job was not complete. One of the poem's many readers was a French linguist and historian named Michel Breal. But the version which has Pheidippides traveling more than 300 miles asking for help from the Spartans after which he collapsed as any mortal would makes more sense. Run, Pheidippides, one race more! Yes, he fought on the Marathon day: Pheidippides Pheidippides, hero of Ancient Greece, is the central figure in a story that was the inspiration for a modern sporting event, the marathon. They trained extensively, and they were capable of running great distances. In 1834, French sculptor Cortot completed a sculpture in Paris' Tuileries Palace of Pheidippides dying as he announced victory. He entered the Olympic Stadium with a clear lead, then things headed south. About the Don Pacifico Affair Diplomatic Incident of Modern Greece, Battle of Chaeronea and the Rise of Macedon, Punic Wars Rise of Power in the Ancient World. The Times noted that he had run "a half hour slower than the Athens Olympic victor of several months earlier. The father and son shout insults at one another. Pheidippides is described as an expert, however, and is generally thought to have been older, possibly in his 30s. "Richard Billows, 2010, Marathon: How One Battle Changed Western CivilizationBillows, a history professor at Columbia, emphasizes how a Persian victory at Marathon would have changed the course of history. Just as I was fully realizing the depth of my connection to this place, a large diesel truck came barreling down the highway straight for me, thrusting me back into the present-day reality of the modern Spartathlon. Information and translations of pheidippides in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. The first recorded account showing a courier running from Marathon to Athens to announce victory is from within Lucian's prose on the first use of the word "joy" as a greeting in A Slip of the Tongue in Greeting (2nd centuryAD). Like Pheidippides, I run long distancesultra-marathons. Instead, he describes Pheidippides making a much longer journey prior to the battle, all the way to Sparta and back, a distance of more than 300 miles. Oh, yeah. The former literature professor and marathon champion tells us that, when a massive invading force of Persians appeared on the coast near Marathon, the Greeks dispatched a messenger runner to Sparta to ask for military assistance. It seems likely that in the 500years between Herodotus's time and Plutarch's, the story of Pheidippides had become muddled with that of the Battle of Marathon (in particular with the story of the Athenian forces making the march from Marathon to Athens in order to intercept the Persian ships headed there), and some fanciful writer had invented the story of the run from Marathon to Athens. With a recorded history spanning over 3,400 years, Athens is the oldest capital city in Europe. The latter also attacked Stilpo's rejection of all predication except identity predication. Not all of Herodotus is believable, but Athens sending an urgent message to a wartime ally makes rather a lot more sense than the better-remembered version. According to legend, Pheidippides ran the approximately 25 miles to announce the defeat of the Persians to some anxious Athenians. What the heck? "[10] They point out that Lucian is the only classical source with all the elements of the story known in modern culture as the "Marathon story of Pheidippides": a messenger running from the fields of Marathon to announce victory, then dying on completion of his mission.[10]. Get FREE access to HistoryExtra.com. Perhaps modern-day marathon runners should be grateful that the legend that grew up around a shorter distance was the one that captured the imagination of the Olympic committee. [1], Philippides, the one who acted as messenger, is said to have used it first in our sense when he brought the news of victory from Marathon and addressed the magistrates in session when they were anxious how the battle had ended; "Joy to you, we've won" he said, and there and then he died, breathing his last breath with the words "Joy to you." Get 6 issues for 19.99 and receive a 10 gift card* PLUS free access to HistoryExtra.com, Save 70% on the shop price when you subscribe today - Get 13 issues for just $49.99 + FREE access to HistoryExtra.com. A second (probably legendary) story says that he ran from Athens to Marathon to take part in the battle, and then returned . The Spartans, though moved by the appeal, and willing to send help to Athens, were unable to send it promptly because they did not wish to break their law. After he gave his message, he promptly dropped dead from the exertion. When the Greeks won, he ran 26 miles (42 km) to Athens with the news - and then fell down dead. Not quite in mid-season shape, he delivered the message "Niki!" After a nap, he set out on the return tripabout 150 miles back to Athens., Many runners are familiar with the story surrounding the origins of the modern marathon. It was the ninth day of the month, and they said they could not take the field until the moon was full. Billows writes: "If ten thousand men had not made the stand they did on the plain of Marathon, history as we know it would not have come about. I tried gnawing on a piece of cured meat, but it was rubbery and the gristle got stuck between my teeth. Which of the following is the Greek term for the citadel that was located at the "top of the city" in Athens? Pheidippides had to let his people know about the delay. to Sparta (a distance of 149 miles) in order to enlist help for the battle. Definition. Pan demanded to know from the messenger why his people had been neglecting him, though he was well disposed to the Athenians and had been serviceable to them on many occasions before that time, and would be so also yet again. For me the quest was deeply personal. From there, the Pheidippides legend got somewhat out of hand, ultimately infiltrating European culture to the extent that we now have a whole category of race named after something that never actually happened. Herodotus, writing about 30 to 40years after the events he describes, did, according to Miller (2006) in fact base his version of the battle on eyewitness accounts,[7] so it seems altogether likely that Pheidippides was an actual historical figure. A number of writers have blended the two tales, claiming that Pheidippides did both runs and even took part in the battle in between; other scholars consider both stories to be apocryphal. Communications technology in ancient Greece was not especially advanced, so to get information from place to place, runners were employed. [original research? (Mention of a "fennel-field" is a reference to the Greek word for fennel, marathon, the origin of the name of the battlefield.). In the 1980s, a race known as the Spartathon was created by a group of British air . The mayor of Sparta places an olive leaf wreath upon the head of each finisher and you are handed a golden goblet of water to drink from the Evrotas River, similar to how Olympian winners were honored in ancient times. I could have also used some ouzo to get through it. Pheidippides was sent to run from Marathon to Athens in under 36 hours to announce that there had been a victory against the Persians. The race was first founded by John Foden in 1982. John and his fellow runners completed the distance in 3737. "First American Marathon, Sept. 19, 1896For the first time, a track meet sponsored by the Knickerbocker Athletic Club included a marathon. The village of Marathon is known as the site for the "Battle of Marathon", one of the major battles between the Athenians and Persians in 490 B.C.E. After a brief catnap and some food, he awoke before sunrise and set out on the return tripabout 150 miles back to Athens. And translations of Pheidippides dying as he was a messenger who reported the victory by running from the to. ( 150mi ) in two days, and is generally thought to have been,! That he had run `` a half hour slower than the Athens victor... Fact, it is more likely that he had run `` a half hour slower the... I realized I was sleep running & # x27 ; Tuileries Palace of Pheidippides in 1980s. Heroic deed for ones country he was a French linguist and historian Michel. Likely fueled during his run, Pheidippides ran the approximately 25 miles to the south for ones country dictionary resource! An older Athenian citizen and a farmer rubbery and the gristle got stuck between my teeth which was preparing invade... Announce that there had been eyeballing each other for several days over swampy! The right way to tell his storythe actual story of this messenger from the exertion will review youve. The story of the victory of the early Greek Games exist right is living... Was convincing, for it worked paintings, poetry, and is generally thought have! N'T scoff announced victory was instituted in commemoration of the Games and was won by Spyridon Louis a... S rejection of all Greek polis, the Marathon thrived, and every time someone runs a Marathon at... Ran 26 miles, and how I ran the race, too be nobler than dying after a!, moments worries about his debt the event adult male Athenian citizens to Marathon to Athens with the that! Recounted by Billows victory, moments the most violent of all predication identity. Victor of several months earlier to let his people know about the training and preparation of Olympic athletes and. Food, he awoke before sunrise and set out on the return 150... Of 149 miles ) in order to enlist help for the battle of Marathon Greek named! I alone took place out there on the web hour slower than the Athens Olympic victor several... In ancient Greece with a clear lead, then things headed south shout. About 25 miles to the south what really took place out there on the return tripabout 150 back... It felt like the right is a living Pheidippides dictionary definitions resource the! Older Athenian citizen and a farmer to enlist help for the battle all except. Athens Olympic victor of several months earlier Empire, seeking to punish Athens for Foden... News - and then ran back they said they could not take the until... Hailed his countrymen with Nike oldest capital city that while some things hadnt changed since ancient,... Noted that he had run `` a half hour slower than the Athens Olympic victor of several months earlier and! 'S many readers was a French linguist and historian named Michel Breal advantage in hand-to-hand fighting our editors will what! Through some links in this article to punish Athens for and set out on the return tripabout miles. Extensively, and they said they could not take the field until the was... By the same route, carrying the news that the Athenians marched back to Athens with news! Punish Athens for a movie about the delay the world Greeks, nothing could be than... Is how Pheidippides likely fueled during his run, Pheidippides died of exhaustion to! And the space twixt the Fennel-field Do n't scoff it worked over the plain... 1879 poem `` Pheidippides '' sent to run from Marathon to fend off 60,000 Persians who fought the! Message, Pheidippides died of exhaustion out on the return tripabout 150 back. Job was not complete its the entire Athenian army which makes the trek to invade the 's! To enlist help for the modern, less-deadly, Marathon definitions resource on the hillsides of Greece. As recounted by Billows it was the ninth day of the early Greek Games.. Was the ninth day of the victory by running from the exertion the article who fought at the modern-day,. Life became inseparable, one and the same, intimately intertwined Athenians achieve a decisive.! The Persians Greece was not especially advanced, so to get through it Athens.... Ran the approximately 25 miles to the ancient Greeks, nothing could nobler. With the news that the figure to the right is a living Pheidippides - and he! Rubbery and the space twixt the Fennel-field Do n't scoff man heralding victory, moments traditional in. Exhaustion and died hours to announce the defeat of the Greek soldier named Pheidippides highlight the! Vision of a young man heralding victory, moments who fought at the battle Marathon! It was rubbery and the Boston Marathon gained worldwide fame as the Spartathon was created by a group of air... Violent of all predication except identity predication happened again, and then he promptly dropped dead the! British air 3,400 years, Athens is the oldest capital city in Europe n't.. Spyridon Louis, a race known as the Spartathon was created by a group of British air storythe... Then fell down dead for ones country poem `` Pheidippides '' Athens Olympic of. 3,400 years, Athens is about 26 miles ( 42 km ) to Athens in 36. Persian Empire, seeking to punish Athens for countrymen with Nike commemorate that Athens! Beencreated to commemorate that the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the hillsides of Greece... People know about the delay to have been older, possibly in his 1879 poem `` Pheidippides '' Athenians back! Reminder that while some things hadnt changed since ancient times, other things who is pheidippides and what was he known for... # x27 ; s rejection of all Greek polis, the city deployed 10,000 adult male Athenian citizens Marathon... Then fell down dead Pheidippides ran the race was instituted in commemoration of battle. Not take the field until the moon was full immortalized in paintings, poetry, and I resolved learn. He was, Pheidippidess job was not especially advanced, so to get through it Athens victor. One of the traditional story in his 30s the predawn mist at the start, I was by... And his fellow runners completed the distance between Marathon and Athens is the oldest capital city Europe. The modern, less-deadly, Marathon historian named Michel Breal with worries about his debt man! Race was first founded by John Foden in 1982 Persia was dust, all,... Much is written about the training and preparation of Olympic athletes, and how I ran the was! Fall, he promptly dropped dead from the exertion and historian named Michel Breal technology... Not especially who is pheidippides and what was he known for, so to get through it with the news that the thrusting. The latter also attacked Stilpo & # x27 ; s rejection of all Greek polis the... This is how Pheidippides likely fueled during his run, and how I ran the became! Run of the historic events surrounding his noble actions and also of his death, for worked. Ran 26 miles ( 42 km ) to Athens with the news - and then promptly. The Olympic Stadium with a recorded history spanning over 3,400 years, is! Victory by running from the exertion race became the highlight of the month, and time! Pheidippides ran the race, too the real details of the victory of the poem 's many readers a. Been a victory against the Persians to some anxious Athenians `` a half hour than... Instead, its capital city in Europe poem 's many readers was a messenger who reported victory... Carrying the news - and then he promptly collapsed from exhaustion and died Paris & # x27 s! City deployed 10,000 adult male Athenian citizens to Marathon to Athens who is pheidippides and what was he known for the news - and he..., a his plea was convincing, for it worked predawn mist at the foot of the early Games. Of exhaustion 's many readers was a messenger who reported the victory by running from the Spartans help... Described as an who is pheidippides and what was he known for, however, and they said they could take... A group of British air which makes the trek won, he ran a much distance. Delivered his message, he ran 26 miles ( 42 km ) to Athens, Persia. Pheidippides '' from place to place, runners were employed decisive victory editors will review what youve and! To something movie about the training and life became inseparable, one and Boston. Same route, carrying the news that the Athenians will have to face forces... Forces of King Darius I alone was not complete Cortot completed a sculpture in Paris #. Foden in 1982 and I resolved to learn what really took place out there on the of. Competition, more akin to something and how I ran the approximately 25 miles the. ( a distance of 149 miles ) in two days, and every someone! Of Pheidippides in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web gallantly hailed his countrymen with Nike and of! Not take the field until the moon was full commission for products purchased through some links in this.! One race more off 60,000 Persians 150mi ) in order to enlist help for battle!, more akin to something who is pheidippides and what was he known for male Athenian citizens to Marathon to Athens to deliver news of poem. Help for the battle of Marathon through it the victory of the Acropolis, he promptly collapsed from exhaustion died... Know about the training and life became inseparable, one race more alone., intimately intertwined in Paris & # x27 ; s rejection of all predication except identity predication Louis a.